It is truly touching to watch the United States government attempt a pivot in the global **critical minerals supply chain**—a problem that has been staring it in the face for two decades. It reminds me of a student realizing they have a major science project due tomorrow morning, except they haven't even bought the poster board yet. This week, the White House gathered representatives from more than 50 countries (including the EU) to address **China’s mining dominance** and the sourcing of **lithium and cobalt**. Fifty countries. Just take a moment to imagine the logistics of that. Imagine trying to get fifty people to agree on what pizza toppings to order. Now, imagine asking them to agree on who controls the literal building blocks of the modern world.

The topic at hand is the undeniable stranglehold of Beijing on the resources that power the **green energy transition**. These are the fancy rocks—lithium, cobalt, nickel—that make your electric car run, your smartphone smart, and the military’s missiles fly. For years, the Western world was perfectly happy to let China do the dirty, dusty, dangerous work of digging this stuff out of the ground and refining it. We sat back in our clean offices, sipping coffee, and congratulating ourselves on moving past the "industrial age." We outsourced the mess. We sold off the mines. We let the supply chains drift away because it was cheaper and easier.

Well, surprise! It turns out that if you let someone else own all the factories and all the mines, they eventually own you. Now, the United States is in a full-blown panic. They have officially launched the **Minerals Security Partnership Finance Network**. It is a very long, boring name for a very desperate attempt to catch up. The goal is to strengthen cooperation and get money flowing to mining projects that aren't controlled by Beijing. It sounds nice on paper. Everything always sounds nice on paper.

The irony here is thick enough to cut with a knife. The same politicians who spent years making it incredibly difficult to dig a hole in the ground in the West are now begging for domestic sourcing. They want "green" energy, which requires batteries, which requires mining. But nobody wants a mine in their backyard. So, they have gathered fifty nations to sit in a room and talk about how to get these minerals without actually getting their hands dirty. They want a magic solution where the rocks just appear, guilt-free and cheap, without having to rely on the one country that actually spent the money and time to build the infrastructure.

Let’s be honest about what a meeting of fifty countries actually achieves regarding **critical minerals**. It achieves a press release. It achieves a group photo where everyone smiles and pretends they are united. But does it dig a mine? No. Does it build a processing plant? No. China didn't build its dominance by holding massive summits with fifty other nations. They did it by buying mines, building roads, and pouring concrete. They played the long game while the West was playing the stock market. While American companies were worried about their quarterly earnings reports, Chinese companies were securing the rights to the cobalt that will power the next twenty years of technology.

This "Finance Network" is supposed to help companies in these fifty countries get the capital they need to start mining. But money isn't the only problem. Time is the problem. It takes ten to fifteen years to get a new mine up and running in a democracy. There are permits, environmental studies, lawsuits, and protests. In a command economy, they just point at a mountain and say, "Dig." The United States thinks it can fight this efficiency with a committee. It is a classic bureaucratic delusion.

This meeting is theater. It is a performance designed to make us feel like there is a plan for the **EV battery supply chain**. It is meant to reassure the public that the people in charge know what they are doing. But if they knew what they were doing, they wouldn't be starting this "plan" in 2024. They would have started it in 2004. Watching fifty countries try to coordinate a supply chain strategy is like watching a herd of cats try to pilot a spaceship. It might be entertaining, but I wouldn't bet my life on them reaching the moon.

The sad reality is that the horse has not only left the barn; the horse has died of old age, and the barn has been converted into condos. Trying to break China's grip on these minerals now is going to be expensive, messy, and slow. But sure, let’s have another meeting about it. Let’s print some more brochures. I’m sure that will scare the competition.

***

### References & Fact-Check * **Original Report**: [BBC News - US launches plan to tackle China's critical minerals dominance](https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c5y41r5rzrno?at_medium=RSS&at_campaign=rss) * **Key Event**: The launch of the **Minerals Security Partnership (MSP) Finance Network** in September 2024. * **Participating Entities**: Over 30 countries and the European Union. * **Primary Objective**: To diversify global supply chains for critical minerals (lithium, nickel, cobalt) away from Chinese market dominance.